Powered by Redpapr

GS Question

Back to 2013 GS2

Back to 2013

Back to Home

Question #

'A national Lokpal, however strong it may be, cannot resolve the problems of immorality in public affairs.' Discuss.

ChatGPT Answer #

The statement suggests that the establishment of a national Lokpal, an ombudsman-like institution in India responsible for addressing corruption complaints against public officials, would not be sufficient to address the problem of immorality in public affairs. While a national Lokpal can play a crucial role in combatting corruption, it is crucial to understand that immorality in public affairs goes beyond corruption alone. This disagreement stems from various factors:

1. Complex nature of immorality: Immorality in public affairs may include corruption, nepotism, favoritism, misconduct, abuse of power, and several other unethical practices. A Lokpal primarily focuses on tackling corruptive acts, and while it can address this aspect of immorality to an extent, it is difficult to expect a single institution to handle the entire spectrum of immoral behavior.

2. Cultural and systemic factors: Immorality in public affairs often stems from deep-rooted cultural and systemic issues present in society. These include the acceptance of unethical behavior, lack of values, weak governance structures, and non-accountability of public officials. A national Lokpal, while essential for addressing specific corruptive acts, may not be able to effectively counter such broad cultural and systemic problems.

3. Political interference: The effectiveness and independence of a national Lokpal may be compromised due to political interference. Politicians who themselves may be involved in immorality might influence the appointment of Lokpal members or weaken their powers. This would hinder the ability of the Lokpal to address immorality in public affairs comprehensively.

4. Limited jurisdiction: A national Lokpal typically has jurisdiction only over public officials. However, immorality also exists in the private sector, civil society, and other areas of public life. Thus, a Lokpal's authority may be restricted, limiting its ability to address immorality in the larger context.

5. Lack of public awareness and participation: The success of a national Lokpal depends on public awareness and proactive citizen involvement. Individuals must report cases, provide evidence, and cooperate with the Lokpal. However, a lack of awareness or apathy among citizens can undermine the effectiveness of the institution.

To address the problems of immorality in public affairs comprehensively, it requires a multi-faceted approach that goes beyond the establishment of a national Lokpal. This approach should include strengthening ethical frameworks, promoting transparency, enhancing accountability, and fostering a culture of integrity in both public and private sectors. Additionally, improving governance structures, promoting awareness, and empowering citizens to actively participate in decision-making processes are essential aspects of tackling immorality in public affairs on a broader scale.

Google Bard Answer #

Coming Soon.

Claude AI Answer #

Coming Soon.