Mahatma Joti Rao Phule's writings and efforts of social reforms touched issues of almost all subaltern classes. Discuss.
Question #11 2025
Joti Rao Phule Social Reforms
Topper's Answer
Mahatma Joti Rao Phule was a pioneer of the socio-cultural renaissance in 19th-century Western India. Unlike early reform movements that were largely urban and elite-centric, Phule’s ideology and activism were deeply rooted in the lived experiences of the marginalized. He conceptualized the idea of a cohesive subaltern identity comprising Shudras (peasants/laborers), Ati-Shudras (untouchables), and women, systematically addressing their exploitation through his writings and grassroots efforts.
Emancipation of Lower Castes and Untouchables (Shudras and Ati-Shudras)
- Writings: In his seminal work, Gulamgiri (1873), Phule launched a blistering critique of the caste system and Brahminical hegemony. By dedicating the book to the American abolitionist movement, he drew global parallels between caste-based untouchability and racial slavery. His play Tritiya Ratna (1855) highlighted how the lack of education kept lower castes in a state of subjugation.
- Efforts: To institutionalize his reform efforts, he founded the Satyashodhak Samaj (Truth Seekers' Society) in 1873, which aimed to liberate lower castes from orthodox socio-religious oppression. He initiated the practice of conducting marriages without Brahmin priests. Leading by example, he opened his private drinking water well to untouchables in 1868, a revolutionary act challenging concepts of ritual purity.
Advocacy for Women’s Empowerment Phule recognized that women, irrespective of their caste, constituted the most oppressed subaltern class due to entrenched patriarchy.
- Efforts: Along with his wife, Savitribai Phule, and Fatima Sheikh, he established the first indigenously run school for girls in India at Bhide Wada (Pune) in 1848. He vehemently opposed female infanticide by establishing the Balhatya Pratibandhak Griha (Infanticide Prohibition Home) in 1863 to protect pregnant widows and illegitimate children.
- Writings: In his posthumously published Sarvajanik Satyadharma Pustak (1891), he dismantled the moral and religious justifications for gender inequality, advocating for equal rights for men and women in society and religion, effectively proposing an egalitarian humanistic religion.
Championing the Peasantry and Agrarian Classes Phule was among the first Indian thinkers to systematically analyze agrarian distress and the exploitation of the peasantry.
- Writings: His book Shetkaryacha Asud (The Cultivator’s Whipcord, 1881) provides a profound socio-economic analysis of the Indian farmer. He detailed how the peasantry was doubly exploited: culturally by the orthodox priesthood and economically by moneylenders and the colonial bureaucracy.
- Efforts: He actively defended the rights of farmers against unjust land revenue policies. During the Hunter Commission of 1882, Phule submitted a memorandum demanding free and compulsory primary education, specifically arguing that educational funds should be directed toward rural, agrarian masses rather than the urban elite.
Pioneering the Labour Movement The genesis of the Indian working-class movement owes a great debt to Phule’s overarching subaltern ideology.
- Efforts: While Phule focused heavily on the peasantry, his associate Narayan Meghaji Lokhande, heavily influenced by Satyashodhak ideology, went on to establish the Bombay Mill Hands Association (1890), India's first labor organization. Phule actively supported efforts to organize textile mill workers, recognizing industrial laborers as a distinct, exploited subaltern class facing miserable working conditions.
Analytical Significance of Phule’s Approach
- Intersectionality: Phule’s genius lay in his intersectional understanding of exploitation. He recognized that caste, class, and gender were inextricably linked in India (Brahminical Patriarchy).
- Education as a Tool for Liberation: He viewed education not merely as a means for employment, but as the Tritiya Ratna (Third Eye)—a tool for critical thinking and subaltern awakening against socio-religious dogma.
- Constructive Over Destructive Reform: He did not just critique the existing order; he built parallel, egalitarian institutions (schools, shelters, alternative religious frameworks) to replace oppressive structures.
For his unparalleled dedication to the masses, social reformer Vithalrao Krishnaji Vandekar bestowed upon him the title of "Mahatma" in 1888. Mahatma Phule’s holistic vision of subaltern emancipation laid the ideological bedrock for the subsequent Dalit-Bahujan movements in India, profoundly shaping the socio-political philosophies of future leaders like Chhatrapati Shahu Maharaj and Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, who rightfully regarded him as one of his three gurus.