Question #4 2025

Climate Change & Island Nations

How are climate change and the sea level rise affecting the very existence of many island nations? Discuss with examples.

Continue to new Website

Answer
Topper's Answer

According to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) Sixth Assessment Report (AR6), global mean sea levels are rising at an unprecedented rate, projected to increase by up to 1 meter by 2100 under high-emission scenarios. For Small Island Developing States (SIDS), which often rest only a few meters above sea level, climate change and sea-level rise are not merely environmental challenges, but profound existential threats that endanger their territorial integrity, economic viability, and statehood.

Multidimensional Existential Threats to Island Nations

1. Territorial Inundation and Physical Submergence The most direct threat of sea-level rise, driven by thermal expansion and the melting of the cryosphere, is the permanent inundation of low-lying atolls. This leads to severe coastal erosion, shrinking the habitable landmass and physically erasing nations from the map.

2. Freshwater Salinization (The Hidden Crisis) Long before an island is physically submerged, it becomes uninhabitable due to saltwater intrusion. Sea-level rise and storm surges push saltwater into fragile underground freshwater lenses (aquifers). Without access to potable water or viable soil for agriculture, the sustenance of human life becomes impossible.

3. Decimation of the "Blue Economy" The economies of SIDS are overwhelmingly dependent on marine ecosystems and coastal tourism. Climate change induces ocean acidification and marine heatwaves, leading to mass coral bleaching. This destroys coral reefs, which act both as natural breakwaters against storms and as nurseries for fisheries, threatening food security and economic survival.

4. Intensification of Extreme Weather Events Warmer ocean temperatures fuel more frequent and intense tropical cyclones. Because island nations have concentrated infrastructure along their coasts, a single super-cyclone can wipe out an entire nation's GDP, destroying homes, hospitals, and power grids, creating a perpetual cycle of destruction and debt.

5. Threat to Sovereignty and Maritime Entitlements Under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), an island generates a 200-nautical-mile Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ). If an island becomes uninhabitable or sinks, nations risk losing their EEZs—which hold their primary economic resources. Furthermore, international law (Montevideo Convention) defines a "State" by a defined territory and permanent population. Climate change creates the unprecedented geopolitical crisis of "statelessness" for climate refugees.

Examples of Island Nations Facing Existential Crises

  • Tuvalu: With its highest point just 4.5 meters above sea level, Tuvalu faces total submergence by the end of the century. Facing the erasure of its physical territory, Tuvalu has launched the "Future Now Project" to create a 'digital twin' of the nation in the metaverse to preserve its history, culture, and sovereign identity. It has also amended its constitution to declare that its statehood will remain in perpetuity, even if its physical land is lost.
  • Kiribati: Confronting severe soil salinization and disappearing shorelines, Kiribati has adopted a policy of "Migration with Dignity." The government preemptively purchased 6,000 acres of land in Fiji to ensure food security and provide a potential relocation site for its citizens, highlighting the reality of forced climate displacement.
  • The Maldives: As the world’s lowest-lying country, with 80% of its landmass below 1 meter above sea level, the Maldives is highly vulnerable to storm surges. To ensure survival, the government is heavily investing in adaptation by pumping sand from the seabed to construct elevated artificial islands, such as Hulhumalé, to resettle its population safely.
  • Vanuatu: While slightly more elevated, Vanuatu is facing an existential threat from extreme weather. Cyclones Pam (2015) and Harold (2020) wiped out over 60% of its GDP. In response to this systemic vulnerability, Vanuatu spearheaded a historic, successful UN resolution requesting the International Court of Justice (ICJ) to issue an advisory opinion on the legal obligations of states to combat climate change.

The Path Forward: A Question of Global Justice

The crisis facing island nations highlights a stark lack of climate justice; SIDS contribute less than 1% to global greenhouse gas emissions yet bear the disproportionate brunt of the impacts.

Addressing this requires a multi-pronged global response:

  • Robust Climate Finance: The operationalization of the Loss and Damage Fund (agreed upon at COP27 and COP28) must be adequately capitalized to help island nations rebuild and relocate.
  • Legal Innovations: International legal frameworks must be updated to freeze maritime baselines, ensuring that island nations retain their EEZ rights and political sovereignty even if their landmass is submerged.
  • Aggressive Mitigation: Adaptation has hard limits. Strict adherence to the Paris Agreement's goal of limiting global temperature rise to 1.5°C is critical to slowing sea-level rise.

The survival of island nations is the ultimate litmus test for the efficacy of global climate governance. Protecting these nations is not merely an act of ecological conservation, but a fundamental imperative of human rights, international security, and global climate justice.

UPSC

Books

Papers

Optional Subjects