home2017gs119

Question #19

Distinguish between religiousness/religiosity and communalism giving one example of how the former has got transformed into the latter in independent India.

edited by

Religiousness or religiosity refers to the personal belief, devotion, and adherence to a particular religion or its practices. It relates to an individual's faith, spirituality, and personal relationship with their religion. On the other hand, communalism refers to the tendency of individuals to prioritize their religious or communal interests over other social, political, or national identities. It involves the promotion of one's own religious group's interests while disregarding or opposing those of other communities.

In independent India, one example of the transformation of religiousness into communalism can be seen during the 1992 Babri Masjid demolition. The Babri Masjid, located in Ayodhya, was a 16th-century mosque that had been a point of contention between Hindus and Muslims for many years. Hindus believed that the mosque was built on the birthplace of Lord Ram, a Hindu deity.

Over time, the issue of the Babri Masjid became highly politicized, and religious sentiments started getting manipulated for political gains. What began as religiousness and faith in their respective religions turned into a highly charged communal conflict. Politicians exploited the religious sentiments of the people to mobilize support. This led to communal violence, culminating in the demolition of the Babri Masjid by a large mob of Hindu activists on December 6, 1992.

The transformation of religiousness into communalism during this incident can be observed through the polarization of the two religious communities. Personal religious beliefs and devotion turned into a clash of identities, resulting in violence and deepening the divide between Hindus and Muslims in India. The incident highlighted how religiousness can be manipulated and transformed into communalism, causing communal tensions and conflicts within a society.

edited by

Religiousness/Religiosity vs. Communalism:

Religiousness/Religiosity: Refers to an individual's personal belief in and practice of a religion. It encompasses aspects like faith, spirituality, ritual observance, and personal piety. It's a private and individualistic matter, focused on one's personal relationship with the divine.

Communalism: Refers to a political ideology that promotes the interests of a particular religious group over others. It often manifests in divisive practices, hostility towards other religious groups, and demands for political dominance based on religious affiliation. It's a social and political phenomenon, using religion as a tool for power and influence.

Key Differences:

  • Focus: Religiousness focuses on individual faith and practice, while communalism focuses on collective identity and political power.
  • Scope: Religiousness is personal and private, while communalism is social and political.
  • Motive: Religiousness stems from individual beliefs and spirituality, while communalism stems from political ambition and desire for dominance.

Example of Religiousness Transforming into Communalism in Independent India:

One example is the rise of the Hindu nationalist movement in India. While Hinduism has long been a major religion in India, it was practiced in diverse forms and communities across the country. However, after independence, certain groups began to promote a specific, exclusionary vision of Hinduism, emphasizing a shared cultural identity and political dominance. This resulted in:

  • Polarization: Promoting the idea of a Hindu "nation" and portraying other religions as "foreign" or "undesirable."
  • Violence: Using religious narratives to incite violence against minority communities, particularly Muslims.
  • Political Gain: Utilizing communal sentiments to garner political support and gain power.

This transformation of religiousness into communalism can be seen in the rise of political parties like the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), which actively promotes a Hindu nationalist agenda and has been accused of using communalism for political gain.

It's crucial to understand that religiousness is a personal matter, while communalism is a dangerous political ideology that undermines social harmony and fosters division.

edited by

What a great question!

Religiousness/religiosity and communalism are two distinct concepts that are often confused or used interchangeably. Understanding the difference between them is crucial, especially in the context of India, where religion and community have played significant roles in shaping society and politics.

Religiousness/Religiosity: Religiousness or religiosity refers to an individual's personal faith, beliefs, and practices related to a particular religion. It involves a personal commitment to a set of spiritual principles, rituals, and values that guide one's thoughts, feelings, and actions. Religiousness is a private and personal affair, where an individual seeks to connect with the divine, find meaning, and experience spiritual growth.

Communalism: Communalism, on the other hand, refers to the promotion of group identity and interests based on religion, caste, or other ascriptive characteristics. It involves the politicization of religious or communal differences, often leading to exclusion, discrimination, or violence against other groups. Communalism is more about asserting group power, dominance, or superiority over others, rather than promoting religious values or spirituality.

Now, let's consider an example of how religiosity has transformed into communalism in independent India:

Example: The Babri Masjid-Ram Janmabhoomi Dispute The Babri Masjid-Ram Janmabhoomi dispute is a prime example of how religiosity was transformed into communalism in India. Until the 1980s, the Ram Janmabhoomi movement was largely a religious and cultural movement, seeking to reclaim the alleged birthplace of Lord Ram in Ayodhya, Uttar Pradesh. Many Hindus believed that the Babri Masjid, a 16th-century mosque, was built on the site of a ancient Hindu temple, and hence, was a symbol of Muslim conquest and oppression.

However, in the late 1980s and early 1990s, the movement took a communal turn, with the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and other Hindutva groups politicizing the issue. The movement became a rallying cry for Hindu nationalism, emphasizing the need for Hindus to reclaim their sacred spaces and assert their cultural dominance. The movement's discourse shifted from a religious-cultural one to a communal-political one, pitting Hindus against Muslims and creating a sense of us-versus-them.

This transformation from religiosity to communalism led to widespread violence, including the demolition of the Babri Masjid in 1992, and several communal riots and massacres in subsequent years. The dispute continues to be a contentious issue in Indian politics, with the Supreme Court's 2019 verdict allowing the construction of a Ram temple at the site, while also ordering the allocation of alternative land for a mosque.

In summary, while religiosity is a personal and spiritual affair, communalism is a political and divisive force that can lead to exclusion, discrimination, and violence. The transformation of religiosity into communalism, as seen in the Babri Masjid-Ram Janmabhoomi dispute, has had far-reaching consequences for India's social and political fabric.