home2018gs210

Question #10

A number of outside powers have entrenched themselves in Central Asia, which is a zone of interest to India. Discuss the implications, in this context, of India's joining the Ashgabat Agreement, 2018.

edited by

India's decision to join the Ashgabat Agreement in 2018 carries significant implications in the context of outside powers' entrenchment in Central Asia. The Ashgabat Agreement is a multimodal transport agreement between Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan, Iran, Kazakhstan, Pakistan, and Oman, aimed at facilitating transit and improving connectivity within the region. By joining this agreement, India seeks to enhance its engagement with Central Asia for several reasons.

Firstly, Central Asia holds strategic importance to India due to its geographical proximity and historical, cultural, and economic linkages. India has long recognized the potential of Central Asia as an energy and trade corridor connecting South Asia, the Middle East, and Eurasia. Therefore, by joining the Ashgabat Agreement, India aims to deepen its economic and trade ties with the Central Asian nations involved.

Secondly, India's involvement in the Ashgabat Agreement allows it to counterbalance the influence of other outside powers that have already entrenched themselves in the region. Central Asia has become a significant playing field for various external actors, including Russia, China, and the United States. These powers have been actively expanding their economic, political, and security engagements in the region, often through the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) and the Eurasian Economic Union (EEU). By joining the Ashgabat Agreement, India asserts its presence and strengthens its position in a region that is considered their zone of interest.

Thirdly, the Ashgabat Agreement enables India to diversify its energy resources and reduce its dependence on traditional suppliers. Central Asia possesses vast reserves of oil, gas, and other minerals, making it an attractive source of energy for energy-importing countries like India. By increasing its connectivity and cooperation in the region, India can access and develop new energy sources, enhancing its energy security.

Furthermore, joining the Ashgabat Agreement aligns with India's broader foreign policy goal of expanding its influence and connectivity initiatives in the Eurasian region. India's Connect Central Asia policy, implemented in 2012, aims to enhance its engagement with the Central Asian countries through connectivity projects, capacity building, cultural exchanges, and trade facilitation. By joining the Ashgabat Agreement, India can integrate its existing efforts with regional initiatives, gaining greater access to markets and forging stronger diplomatic ties.

In conclusion, India's decision to join the Ashgabat Agreement in 2018 has significant implications in the context of outside powers' entrenchment in Central Asia. It allows India to enhance economic ties, counterbalance the influence of other external actors, diversify its energy sources, and strengthen its overall engagement in the region. By joining this regional agreement, India bolsters its position and marks its presence in a zone of interest that holds great importance for its geopolitical and strategic interests.

edited by

India's Ashgabat Agreement: Navigating Geopolitical Currents in Central Asia

The Ashgabat Agreement, signed in 2018, is a multimodal transport agreement between Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, Afghanistan, and Iran. It provides for a simplified framework for transit of goods between the four countries, aiming to bolster regional trade and economic cooperation. India's recent entry into the agreement, in June 2022, holds significant implications for its strategic interests in Central Asia, where several external powers are vying for influence.

Implications for India:

1. Access to Central Asian Markets: The agreement opens up direct access to Central Asian markets for Indian goods, bypassing traditional routes through Pakistan or Russia. This facilitates trade, investment, and economic cooperation, further strengthening India's ties with Central Asian nations.

2. Countering Chinese Influence: China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) has been highly influential in Central Asia. India's involvement in the Ashgabat Agreement presents a counterweight to Chinese dominance, offering alternative trade routes and fostering cooperation independent of Beijing's influence.

3. Strategic Geopolitical Position: By participating in the agreement, India gains a strategic foothold in Central Asia. This facilitates closer engagement with regional actors, enabling India to play a more active role in shaping the geopolitical landscape of the region.

4. Enhancing Regional Connectivity: The agreement promotes regional connectivity, facilitating trade and people-to-people exchanges between India and Central Asian countries. This fosters cultural and economic ties, strengthening India's soft power in the region.

5. Security Concerns: While offering opportunities, the agreement also presents challenges. The transit route passes through Afghanistan, a region plagued by instability. India needs to ensure security along the corridor and address the potential risks posed by extremist groups operating in the region.

6. Competition with Russia: Russia, another influential power in Central Asia, may perceive India's participation in the agreement as a challenge to its interests. India will need to navigate its relationship with Russia carefully to avoid fueling tensions and maintain its strategic partnerships.

Overall, India's entry into the Ashgabat Agreement is a significant move with wide-ranging implications. It offers an opportunity for India to strengthen its ties with Central Asian countries, diversify its economic and strategic interests, and counter Chinese influence in the region.

However, India needs to address the security challenges posed by the transit route and carefully navigate its relationships with other regional powers to ensure a stable and beneficial outcome.

The agreement's success will depend on the commitment of all participating countries to ensure its effective implementation and on India's ability to leverage its participation to further its strategic objectives in Central Asia.

edited by

Central Asia is a strategically important region that connects Europe and Asia, and its significance has increased in recent years due to its natural resources, geographical location, and growing economic opportunities. India has been seeking to strengthen its presence in the region to counterbalance the influence of other powers, particularly China, and to promote its economic and strategic interests. In this context, India's joining the Ashgabat Agreement in 2018 has significant implications.

The Ashgabat Agreement is a transport corridor agreement signed in 2011 between Oman, Iran, Turkmenistan, and Uzbekistan, aiming to create a new transportation route connecting the Gulf region to Central Asia and Europe. In 2018, India became the fifth member country to join the agreement.

Implications of India's joining the Ashgabat Agreement:

  1. Enhanced connectivity: India's participation in the Ashgabat Agreement will enable it to establish a direct transportation route to Central Asia, bypassing Pakistan and Afghanistan. This will increase India's connectivity with the region, facilitating the transportation of goods, energy, and people.
  2. Counterbalancing China: By joining the Ashgabat Agreement, India aims to counterbalance China's growing influence in Central Asia. The Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) has increased China's presence in the region, and India's move is seen as a response to this growing Chinese presence.
  3. Economic benefits: The Ashgabat Agreement offers India an opportunity to tap into the vast natural resources of Central Asia, including oil, natural gas, and minerals. This can help India reduce its dependence on other energy sources and diversify its energy imports.
  4. Geopolitical significance: India's presence in the Ashgabat Agreement can help it expand its influence in the region, challenging the traditional dominance of Russia and China. This can also help India strengthen its position in the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO), a regional security grouping.
  5. Increased trade: The agreement is expected to boost trade between India and Central Asia, increasing India's exports of goods and services to the region. This can help India reduce its trade deficit with Central Asia and increase its economic footprint in the region.
  6. Strategic implications: India's participation in the Ashgabat Agreement can also have strategic implications, as it can help India monitor and address potential security threats from the region, including terrorism and instability.
  7. Regional integration: India's joining the Ashgabat Agreement can contribute to regional integration, as it will help create a more interconnected transportation network in Central Asia, promoting economic cooperation and development.

In conclusion, India's joining the Ashgabat Agreement has significant implications for its strategic and economic interests in Central Asia. By enhancing connectivity, counterbalancing Chinese influence, and promoting economic cooperation, India can strengthen its position in the region and increase its influence. However, it is essential to note that the success of the agreement will depend on the effective implementation of its provisions and the ability of member countries to work together to overcome challenges and promote regional cooperation.